So it's like this. Like the media slave I am, I got sucked into the 24/7 coverage of the Tookie Williams execution case as it approached the 11th hour.
Now this is complicated for me because I bounce between being an opponent to the death penalty and applying logic relative to the California penal system.
The obvious argument that everyone is being hit over the head with is that Tookie Williams is a changed man and is not the man he was when he was convicted. It's easy to get sucked into that. However, as I got to thinking more about it I realized that I don't actually care about the good work he's done. I'm sure if you got to know a lot of the guys on death row a lot of them will have made a change toward good. A death sentence can be a sobering event.
But all that being said, simply put I think the death penalty is wrong and I'll argue clemency for anyone on death row because I've yet to find a fool proof justice system that can assure me that innocent people will not be put to death.
Look at Chicago for God's sake. The governor had to set aside the death sentences for over 100 inmates because of corruption and unethical behaviour by the prosecution.
Can you IMAGINE, being on death row for a crime you did not commit? David Milgaard owes his life to today to the fact that we as Canadians have more second thought than to equate justice with vengeance. Proponents of the Tookie execution will say that he's had 24 years to uncover new evidence but hey, it took almost as long to get Milgaard out of prison. Good God, if he were in Texas he wouldn't have made it 1/2 that long.
I can't believe in 2005 America, the global cheerleader of humanity and democracy, could allow within it's own borders, practices that I'm sure history will regard as nothing less than barbarbic and archaic. I say this not of the act of the killing itself, which of course we agree is heinous, but of the system's, and dare I say the people's, ability to rationalize their own failures into 'we'll try our best not kill the wrong person'.
Anyway, as I write this CNN is reporting that another man has been killed in Missouri. I guess he didn't have celebrities on his side to warrant more coverage. All the same he's dead, his victims aren't any more alive for it. The families don't hurt any less. No future murders are being deterred as a result. God Bless America.
"Crime and punishment grow out of one stem. Punishment is a fruit that unsuspected ripens within the flower of the pleasure which concealed it." ~ Ralph Waldo Emerson. "Compensation." In Compensation and Heroism. New York, Boston, H.M. Caldwell Co.,
1900. p 15